Paving the path: Addressing market imbalances to achieve quality and affordable childcare in more places
REPORT

Paving the path: Addressing market imbalances to achieve quality and affordable childcare in more places

clock

22.10.2024 - 08:29

EducationChildcare

Our latest report, in partnership with The Front Project, examines how Australia's childcare sector has evolved and the growing imbalances in service provision. Long Day Care (LDC) centres, which form the backbone of Australia's childcare system, have seen supply increase by 69% since 2013. However, this growth has been dominated by for-profit providers and is unevenly distributed. In low SES areas, there are 41% fewer LDC places than in high SES areas. Not-for-profit providers, who deliver higher quality care and charge lower fees on average, have seen their market share decline particularly in metropolitan and gentrifying areas. The report highlights the need for policy intervention to ensure quality and affordable childcare is available to all families.

Rising demand has driven an increase in the supply of long day care centres

The demand for childcare services has grown substantially, driven by three key factors: increasing female workforce participation, child population growth, and expanded government funding. Female workforce participation for ages 25-44 has risen by 27 percentage points since 1981, while the under-7 population has grown by over 500,000. Government funding has increased by 14% annually since 1981, making childcare more accessible to families.

In response to this growing demand, Long Day Care (LDC) services, which account for 52% of all early childhood education and care services, has expanded significantly. Supply of LDC places has increased by 69% since 2013, from 401,000 to 675,000 places. This growth has been achieved through both the establishment of over 2,700 new centres and the expansion of existing facilities, with average centre capacity increasing from 63 to 74 children.

portableText image

LDC supply growth has been uneven across regions and provider types

Low socio-economic, and remote areas have relatively poor access to LDC services

Despite strong overall supply growth, there are noticeable disparities in childcare accessibility. Low socioeconomic areas face significant challenges, with 41% fewer LDC places per 100 children compared to high socioeconomic areas. The geographic divide is equally concerning - while metropolitan areas enjoy good access to services, 109 Local Government Areas, primarily in rural communities, still have no LDC services at all.

portableText image

Increasingly, for-profit providers are dominating the market, but they are concentrated in metro and gentrifying areas

The childcare market has seen a significant shift in provider composition, with for-profit providers increasing their market share from 60% to 70% since 2013, while not-for-profit providers have declined from 32% to 23%. However, this dominance is not uniform across regions. For-profit providers have established a particularly strong presence in major cities, where they now operate 75% of services, up from 63% in 2013. In contrast, they make up only 15% of services in remote and very remote areas, where not-for-profit providers remain the backbone of childcare, operating over two-thirds of services.

portableText image

The impact of market forces is particularly evident in gentrifying areas, where changing demographics and rising costs are reshaping the provider landscape. Between 2021 and 2024, these areas saw a 25% increase in for-profit places while not-for-profit places declined by 10%. This trend likely reflects the rising operational costs in gentrifying areas, particularly rent increases, which favour providers with stronger profit margins.

portableText image

Not-for-profit providers excel in quality, wages and affordability

Not-for-profit providers on average demonstrate better performance across quality, staff wages and affordability. In terms of service quality, 28% of not-for-profit LDCs are rated above the National Quality Standard, compared to just 15% of for-profits.

Employment practices also differ significantly, with 95% of staff in large not-for-profits receiving above-award wages, compared to 64% in large for-profits. Not-for-profits also have higher educator-to-child ratios and staff retention rates.

Affordability remains a key advantage of not-for-profit providers. Among large providers, only 15% of not-for-profits charge above the hourly rate cap, compared to 43% of for-profits.

portableText image

As supply grows policy needs to ensure a balanced market to provide quality and affordable care

As Australia moves toward improving childcare access and inclusion, policy needs to address the growing market imbalances particularly in metropolitan and gentrifying areas. Policies should support quality and affordable care across all markets. Supporting not-for-profits in larger markets enables them to cross-subsidise services in thinner markets. This ensures not-for-profits are sustainable across different market types, improving care quality and affordability for all Australian families.

Read and download the full report.

Read our latest posts

The Australian Health and Medical Research Workforce Audit
Health

The Australian Health and Medical Research Workforce Audit

The Australian Health and Medical Research Workforce Audit provides a detailed snapshot of Australia’s health and medical research workforce, highlighting its characteristics, career pathways, and challenges. Drawing on desktop research, surveys, and profile analysis, the report reveals that approximately 39,690 researchers work in the field, with 65% in traditional university and institute roles and 33% in private and clinical settings. Although women make up 52% of the workforce, only 25% hold senior positions, indicating a gender gap in leadership. Over 40% of researchers are from overseas, adding diversity and global connections, while Victoria employs the most researchers, with a notable underrepresentation in regional and remote areas. Despite a shared passion for research and societal impact, many researchers face challenges with funding and job security, and in the past five years, over 60% have moved into non-research roles where they continue to contribute as leaders and managers in related fields. This audit provides valuable insights into the strengths and development opportunities within Australia’s health and medical research workforce.

12 Nov, 2024

Beyond the visa cap: Why restricting international students won't solve Australia's housing crisis
Education

Beyond the visa cap: Why restricting international students won't solve Australia's housing crisis

Our latest report in partnership with Student Accommodation Council examines the impact that the Government’s proposed international student visa caps will have on Australia’s metropolitan rental markets. The report demonstrates that while visa caps would significantly harm Australia's economy, they would do little to address housing affordability. International students comprise only 6% of Australia's rental market, with 39% living outside the general rental market entirely. The proposed caps would reduce metropolitan rents by just $5 per week while costing the Australian economy $4.1 billion in GDP and 22,000 jobs. Universities would face $600 million in annual revenue losses. As Australia's fourth-largest export, international education contributes $63 billion to the economy and supports 335,000 jobs. Rather than capping student numbers, the report recommends addressing housing affordability through targeted policies, including reducing tax barriers to foreign investment in student housing and developing purpose-built student accommodation (PBSA) specific legislation. These measures would help maintain Australia's competitive edge while addressing housing pressures through increased PBSA supply.

11 Nov, 2024

Australia’s opportunity in the new AI economy
TechnologyAI

Australia’s opportunity in the new AI economy

Our latest research collaboration with Microsoft has just been released, highlighting Australia's most promising opportunities in the new global AI economy. This study identifies key areas where Australia can leverage its strengths in AI applications, AI data centres, and data to drive significant economic growth, create new jobs, and enhance our digital resilience.

7 Nov, 2024

How online retail boosts Australian small and medium businesses
Retail

How online retail boosts Australian small and medium businesses

Small and medium businesses (SMBs) power Australia's economy, but they haven't reached their full potential. These businesses - defined as having fewer than 200 employees - employ 66 per cent of our workforce and generate 56 per cent of GDP. However, the productivity rate of SMBs, defined as revenue per worker, is 33 per cent lower than large businesses. Mandala research shows that SMBs that adopt online retail channels earn 2.2 times more revenue and are 45 per cent more productive than their offline peers. Nonetheless, only 12 per cent of all SMBs currently use online retail channels. Because SMBs represent such a large share of the economy, even a small increase in productivity would have big impacts. For example, if SMBs were to increase their adoption rate of online retail channels from 12 per cent to 15 per cent, Australia’s GDP would increase by $1.6B, equivalent to $154 per household each year.

31 Oct, 2024

Loading...