The Fragmentation Tax
23.02.2026 - 05:11
Australian retailers operate across a patchwork of inconsistent state and territory regulations that, left unchecked, will cost the economy $26 billion and households $9.4 billion over the next decade. Commissioned by the Australian Retail Council, this Mandala report finds that regulatory fragmentation in retail - Australia's second-largest employer, generating $649 billion in economic activity annually - is compounding the country's productivity crisis at the worst possible time. The report identifies specific issues in transport and logistics, and packaging and waste as priority areas for reform, where harmonisation alone would inject up to $1.65 billion into the economy over 10 years. It recommends the Federal Government use its National Competition Policy framework to drive reform - including a $260 million increase to the National Productivity Fund, a new National Harmonisation Council, and a mandate that Regulatory Impact Statements explicitly quantify fragmentation risks.
Australians are struggling with high prices while weak productivity growth reduces their wages and living standards. Addressing regulatory inconsistencies in one of the most systemic sectors and biggest employers in the economy - the retail sector - is a unique opportunity to help address both these challenges at once.
To support retail is to support the economy. The retail sector is the second largest employer in the country. It employs over 1.5 million Australians and generates $649 billion of income for the Australian economy every year. The retail sector is highly systemic. It permeates throughout the economy and is a critical part of the supply chain for almost every business in Australia. This presents a significant opportunity: addressing problems in the retail sector is one of the biggest-bang-for-buck reforms the government can pursue.
Left unchecked, inconsistent state and territory regulations will cost the Australian economy $26 billion and cost households $9.4 billion over the next 10 years. Regulatory inconsistencies mean retailers face unnecessary costs as they contort their business operations to deal with inconsistent approaches to regulation. It means a retailer transporting goods from one state to another may have to change trucks at the border. It means fleet managers must design elaborate delivery plans when neighbouring local councils have different delivery curfew regulations. It means national retailers need to procure different types of cups in different states to meet fragmented regulatory requirements.
Areas for immediate reform are in transport and logistics, and in packaging and waste reduction regulations. Transporting goods across Australia is a regulatory challenge. Heavy vehicle standards, accreditation and permit processes, commercial vehicle standards, and fatigue management requirements are inconsistent. Harmonising these regulations alone would inject $1 to $1.3 billion into the economy over 10 years.
Packaging and waste reduction regulations are riddled with jurisdictional inconsistencies. Container deposit schemes and bans on single-use plastics vary. Cleaning up these regulatory inconsistencies alone would add $300 to $350 million to the economy over 10 years.
The Federal Government should use its National Competition Policy framework to prioritise cross-jurisdictional reforms in the retail sector. To achieve this the Commonwealth Government should:
- Increase the National Productivity Fund by $260M to support regulatory harmonisation
- Establish a National Harmonisation Council within the NCC to drive cross-jurisdiction decisions and delivery
- Deliver the first harmonised regulatory package within 12 months
- Mandate that Regulatory Impact Statements explicitly acknowledge and quantify fragmentation risks
Read the full report here.
Read our latest posts
The Stagnant Nation: Lifting Australia’s Dynamism
Australians are going backwards on real wages and income. Real wage growth has fallen from 0.6 per cent in the 2000s to -0.7 per cent today, the slowest rate since the 1990s recession. Weak productivity growth is a key driver. Productivity growth has dropped from 2.2 per cent in the 1990s to just 0.1 per cent today. The Productivity Commission has pointed to declining economic dynamism as one cause for weak growth, with fewer businesses starting, growing and competing. We confirm declining economic dynamism across five key dimensions and estimate that reversing this decline seen since the mid-2000s could see a GDP uplift of $101 billion per year over the next decade. Our analysis finds that regulation could account for around 20 per cent of declining dynamism. Reducing regulatory burden to late-2000s levels could see GDP uplift of at least $20 billion per year over the next ten years.
7 Oct, 2026
Demonstrating the economic benefits of Airwallex in Australia
Mandala's latest research, commissioned by Airwallex, quantifies the direct and indirect economic benefits of Airwallex in Australia. Airwallex supported $4.6 billion in economic benefits in 2025, a figure roughly equivalent to 2 per cent of the Australian tech sector's contribution to GDP. Of this, $2.5 billion flows directly to platform businesses through productivity gains, new market access and cost savings, with the remainder reaching the broader economy as those benefits move through customers' supply chains. Airwallex supports 29,000 jobs across the Australian economy, and a quarter of economic benefits flow to regional, rural and remote areas. Small and medium businesses capture the largest share of any business segment on the platform, $2.1 billion annually, or $200,000 in economic benefits for the average SMB each year.
16 Sep, 2026
Power to the people
Mandala’s latest research examines how Greater Manchester turned devolved power into economic growth, why it worked, and what it could mean if similar powers were extended across England. Since devolution began in 2009, Greater Manchester’s economy has grown by nearly 45%, outperforming both the rest of England and the UK as a whole. Greater control over funding and policy has enabled the Mayor and Greater Manchester Combined Authority (GMCA) to coordinate investment in transport, housing, skills and economic development around local priorities. This has supported a 41% increase in bus journeys, recycled £300m of government capital into around £1bn of housing investment, delivering 11,000 dwellings, and increased employment in key sectors by over a quarter, compared with 14% across England. Integrating health and social care has also improved life expectancy, with the largest gains in self-reported health in the least healthy neighbourhoods. If local and combined authorities in England had these powers and replicated Manchester, we estimate an annual boost to the economy of up to £80bn, over 93,000 new homes, and £3.1bn in additional economic activity from improved life expectancy.
7 Sep, 2026
The Hidden Economy: Addressing Australia’s Domestic Work and Care Divide
Mandala’s research, in partnership with DoorDash Australia, examines the scale and distribution of Australia's unpaid household labour, the real costs it imposes on individuals and the economy, and the role that emerging technologies and policy reform could play in reducing and more equitably sharing that burden.
6 Sep, 2026